I can't tell you a lot about superwinch or milemarker, but I have both warn and ramsey winches and are very happy with both. I do think the ramsey is a cut above the warn. I have the remote too and do not use it much.
That and it has been stepped up from 2,500 lbs to 3,000 lbsTHE 3.0 IS SUPPOSED TO BE SEALED EVEN BETTER FOR THE WATER
Buy the Warn 3.0. You will not be disappointed. The best price is at www.rockymountainatv.com at $359 plus the mount.
heck i like my Milemarker 3500. got it for $229.95 shipped.. Love it! pulls really slow but a STRONG winch. its amazing. i even got a Warn mini rocker and put it on the handlebar.. my friend has a warn 3.0 on his rancher and something has either stripped or the clutch aint engaging all the way? Got to tear it down to see whats the matter....