Congrads on the new Foreman MudKing. Since your own words are: "I want to keep the Foreman in as good of shape as possible, for as long as possible" You should go with the brushguard, I know with the winch you'll sink it in every hole you can find knowing if you don't make it you'll just winch yourself out, which will not keep your Foreman new for long. But I really enjoy the security of a winch. Good luck with your choice.