folks that like more mud looking tires, love Mudbugs
and I have loved my 589's work well all over for me and wear very well
the main question I suggest you think about is THIS
what is the MOST common ground type you ride on
be it rocks, gravel, snow, hills or water/mud
and pick a tire that is known BEST in that area, rather than trying to find a do it all tire
as every tire has a flaw some place or many!
most folks IMO< way over think tires! looking for that magic one that does it all!
10 yrs or so on my 589's, in all 4 seasons on all types of ground, ONLY time I ever got stuck was when I high centered it and lifted tires off the ground?
as I bet is when 9% of all riders get stuck any how
rather proving most all tires get you thur it till then!
unless your racing and NEED every advantage you can,
basic tires get you thru it all in MOST all tires made today! just being honest!
drinking the cooaid is more common than not, in MUST have things!!